Ekaterina Ponchak

    A free website made with AI: does it work?

    If AI can build a website in minutes, why pay a professional? The honest answer, with Google's own rules

    Author
    Ekaterina Ponchak
    Published
    Reading time
    9 min
    Share
    A free website made with AI: does it work?

    "If I make my website for free with artificial intelligence, will it work? And if it does, why should I pay a professional?" Many business owners ask me exactly that, sometimes almost apologetically, as if it were a naive question. It isn't. It's the right question to ask before you spend a single euro, and it deserves a straight answer.

    This article is for you if you run a business, websites aren't your job and AI makes you a little suspicious. No jargon: I'll explain what you get for free, where the free version stops and what Google says, using its official rules.

    The short answer: it depends on what you mean by "work"

    If "work" means having a web address with a few pages, yes. A free generator will produce a website, even in a few minutes.

    For a business, though, a website works when three things happen: someone finds it, understands why they should choose you and knows how to contact you. The free version gets you online. Those three things are still left to do, and no tool does them on its own. They come from the decisions behind the site: what to write, for whom, in answer to which searches.

    What a free generator gives you

    The difference shows up as soon as you put the two ways of working side by side.

    Automatically generated websiteYou answer a few questions and a few minutes later a whole website comes out. The text and images are whatever the machine imagines for a business "like yours".

    Website built by a professional who uses AIThe starting point is you, your customers and what they search for. AI speeds up the repetitive parts. The decisions and the review of every line stay with me.

    I'm not dismissing generators. If you need a simple page with opening hours, address and phone number, they can be enough. The limit is somewhere else: they don't know your trade. Picture a garage that only works on vans and commercial vehicles. A generator will write "quality car repairs", a sentence that would fit any garage in the country, including one that has nothing to do with yours.

    Where the free version stops

    The design of a generated website is often clean. The problems lie in three jobs that no generator does for you, and that I don't hand over to AI either.

    • Knowing what your business sells: which jobs pay you best, which customers you want and which you don't. That's something you have to tell me.

    • Checking the facts: prices, opening hours, certifications, delivery times. Google itself warns that generative models don't retrieve facts and can get things wrong, and recommends checking every text by hand before publishing it (Google's guidance on AI-generated content). I do that check myself.

    • Deciding what not to write: a text that promises everything to everyone convinces no one.

    There's a limit on my side too, and I'll tell you up front: if you don't give me real information about your work, I can't make it up. A website without your input stays generic, whatever the tool.

    Why a website brings no customers, free or paid

    When a website stays silent, the reason is usually one of these four. None of them depends on the tool it was built with.

    • Nobody finds it: a new website doesn't show up by itself. If nobody in your area searches for what you offer, or the site doesn't answer those searches, it's a shop window on a street with no passers-by.

    • It says what everyone says: "quality, professionalism, experience" is on every website. The person choosing finds no reason to call you rather than someone else.

    • The next step is missing: a hidden phone number, a contact form that reaches nobody, wrong opening hours. The customer was ready and leaves.

    • Your market doesn't go through the internet: a practice that works on word of mouth with a few regular clients uses its website as a business card, and that's fine. Expecting new enquiries from it would be a mistake.

    My adviceBefore you commission any website, or build one yourself for free, open Google and search for what you sell the way one of your customers would type it. Look at who shows up. If competitors show up, someone is searching for that service. If nobody shows up, maybe nobody searches for it, and it's better to find out before you spend time or money.

    Before you say yes to a quote, you need to know what to ask. I've put together 7 questions to ask anyone who offers you a website built with AI, with space to note the answers. They work even if you end up choosing another provider.

    Open the 7 questions to ask before you choose

    What about Google? Does it penalise websites made with AI?

    It's the most common worry, and my opinion isn't needed here: Google has put it in writing. On 8 February 2023 it published guidance on AI-generated content explaining that it rewards the quality of content, not the way it was produced. The criteria are what it calls E-E-A-T: experience, expertise, authoritativeness and trustworthiness. In the same guidance it states that using AI gives no special advantage: it's content like any other.

    On 5 March 2024 Google added another piece with a post on its new spam policies. There it defines scaled content abuse: pages produced in large numbers to manipulate search results, with little value for the reader. The rule applies however the pages are created, whether the text is automated, written by hand or a mix of both.

    On Google's spam policies page the examples are clear: using generative AI to produce many pages with no value, or pages that make little sense to the reader but are packed with search keywords.

    Here's an example of my own. Hundreds of near-identical pages, "plumber in Brescia", "plumber in Verona", "plumber in Mantua", where only the city name changes, fall under that rule. An eight-page website explaining what you do, for whom and in which cases does not.

    An honest limit: no Google rule guarantees you a ranking, with AI or without it. The rules say what to avoid and what gets rewarded. The rest depends on the competition in your sector and your area.

    So what is a professional for?

    For the parts the free version skips. I use AI too, every day: it saves me time on drafts and repetitive work. The decisions stay mine: which pages are needed, what goes on each one, what to cut, and checking every fact before it goes live.

    When I build a website I start from the real searches in my client's sector and decide the pages from there. I explained this in the article on the marketing-injected business website, and you'll find it summarised on the page about how I work on websites for small businesses. If you run a hotel or a B&B and already have a website, also have a look at the options for rebuilding a hotel or B&B website.

    What I would do in your placeI would only accept a website made with AI if whoever builds it can tell me who checked the text and which of my information they started from. The test is this: behind every page there must be something true that only you know.

    And if your budget today is zero? Go ahead and start with a generator, for the simple page with opening hours and phone number. Just be aware of what you're getting: an online presence. When you want the website to bring in enquiries, you'll need someone who starts from your trade and from what your customers are searching for.

    Frequently asked questions

    Can ChatGPT create a website?

    It can write text and page drafts if you ask it to. What it doesn't know is what you sell, to whom and what sets you apart from your competitors. If you don't tell it, it writes generic text, like any generator.

    How can I tell if a website was made with AI?

    Try this: take a sentence from the home page and replace the business name with a competitor's. If the sentence still works, it's generic text, whether a machine or a person wrote it. It tells you less about the tool than about how much care went into it.

    Does Google penalise websites made with artificial intelligence?

    Not for the tool. Google judges the quality of the content and penalises pages mass-produced to manipulate results, however they were written.

    Do I have to say on my website that it was made with AI?

    Google suggests disclosing it when readers might wonder how a piece of content was produced, and advises against listing AI as the author. The name that signs the website is still yours.

    Is a website made with AI by a professional less professional?

    It depends on who decides and who checks. AI speeds up the work, the responsibility for every line stays with whoever signs it.

    Want to know whether the free version is enough for you? Tell me about your business.

    I look at what you sell, who is searching for you and what is already online in your sector. Then I tell you honestly whether a free generator is enough, whether you need a website built around you or whether you can wait for now. If you do need a website, I build it myself, with AI where it saves me time and by hand where judgement is needed.

    Write to me through the contact form: I'll answer you myself, in person →

    Key takeaways

    1. 01A free generator gets you online, but a website works when someone finds it, chooses you and gets in touch
    2. 02The free version doesn't know your trade, doesn't check facts and doesn't know what to leave out
    3. 03Google judges the quality of the content, not the tool used to produce it
    4. 04Google penalises pages mass-produced to manipulate results, whoever writes them
    5. 05A professional decides what to say and to whom, and checks every line before it goes live
    Ekaterina Ponchak
    Written by

    Ekaterina Ponchak

    I build websites and custom web apps, and I handle SEO and digital marketing for Italian small and mid-sized businesses. I turn an online presence into real enquiries.

    LinkedIn
    LET'S START

    Want to apply it to your website?

    You've read the guide, now it's about applying it. I'll work alongside you on an implementation built around your business.

    Fields marked with * are required.

    Complete the security check above to enable sending.

    I reply within 24 hours. Your details stay confidential. Privacy policy

    Prefer to skip ahead? Message me on WhatsApp

    WhatsApp · Fastest reply+39 379 304 1189Phone+39 379 304 1189Email · Reply within 24hinfo@ekaterinaponchak.com
    AreaOnline everywhere · In person around Brescia, Verona, Mantua and Lake Garda
    What you get from the consultation
    • An honest opinion on what you actually need
    • A realistic estimate of time and cost
    • No commitment, just concrete value